Last updated 2/1/2024
| Round 1 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Mike Schmidt |
| 2 | Springfield | Dwight Evans |
| 3 | Tidewater | Davey Lopes |
| 4 | Third Coast | Buddy Bell |
| 5 | Wichita | Rick Reuschel |
| 6 | Kansas City | Bob Boone |
| 7 | Texas | Gary Matthews |
| 8 | Topsail Beach | Dick Tidrow |
| 9 | Grindstone | Garry Maddox |
| 10 | Cape Fear | Rich Gossage |
| 11 | Frankfort | Roric Harrison |
| 12 | Calgary | Doc Medich |
| 13 | Cooperstown | Dave Goltz |
| 14 | Wichita from Mudville | Jim Bibby |
| 15 | Flushing | Lynn McGlothen |
| 16 | West Essex | Jorge Orta |
| Round 2 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Doug Rau |
| 2 | Springfield | Al Bumbry |
| 3 | Tidewater | Gene Garber |
| 4 | Third Coast | Steve Busby |
| 5 | Wichita | Elias Sosa |
| 6 | Kansas City | Steve Yeager |
| 7 | Texas | Bill Robinson |
| 8 | Topsail Beach | Tom Walker |
| 9 | Grindstone | Johnny Grubb |
| 10 | Cape Fear | Lee Lacy |
| 11 | Frankfort | Leroy Stanton |
| 12 | Calgary | Randy Moffitt |
| 13 | Cooperstown | Cy Acosta |
| 14 | Wichita from Mudville | Ken Reitz |
| 15 | Flushing | Dave Hamilton |
| 16 | West Essex | Fred Beene |
| Round 3 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Enos Cabell |
| 2 | Springfield | Balor Moore |
| 3 | Tidewater | Ron Schueler |
| 4 | Third Coast | Tom Hilgendorf |
| 5 | Mudville from Wichita | Cliff Johnson |
| 6 | Kansas City | Lerrin LaGrow |
| 7 | Texas | Larvell Blanks |
| 8 | Topsail Beach | Don Newhauser |
| 9 | Grindstone | Don Stanhouse |
| 10 | Cape Fear | Earl Stephenson |
| 11 | Frankfort | Johnny Oates |
| 12 | Calgary | Dave Tomlin |
| 13 | Cooperstown | Brent Strom |
| 14 | Grindstone from Mudville | Rich Coggins |
| 15 | Flushing | Jerry Morales |
| 16 | West Essex | Glenn Borgmann |
| Round 4 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Rick Auerbach |
| 2 | Springfield | Frank Duffy |
| 3 | Tidewater | Mac Scarce |
| 4 | Third Coast | Dave W. Roberts |
| 5 | Wichita | Mike Strahler |
| 6 | Kansas City | Jack Brohamer |
| 7 | Texas | Buddy Bradford |
| 8 | Topsail Beach | Tommy McCraw |
| 9 | Grindstone | Ray Bare |
| 10 | Cape Fear | Steve Hovley |
| 11 | Frankfort | Carmen Fanzone |
| 12 | Calgary | Dave Lemonds |
| 13 | Cooperstown | Tom Grieve |
| 14 | Mudville | Darrel Chaney |
| 15 | Flushing | Tony Muser |
| 16 | West Essex | Tom Hutton |
| Round 5 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | John Boccabella |
| 2 | Springfield | Dan McGinn |
| 3 | Tidewater | Mike Kilkenny |
| 4 | Third Coast | Bill Slayback |
| 5 | Mudville from Wichita | Mike Cosgrove |
| 6 | Kansas City | Mike Ferraro |
| 7 | Texas | Hal Breeden |
| 8 | Topsail Beach | Jerry Kenney |
| 9 | Grindstone | Mike Hegan |
| 10 | Cape Fear | Rowland Office |
| 11 | Frankfort | Terry Crowley |
| 12 | Calgary | Steve Hargan |
| 13 | Cooperstown | Dwain Anderson |
| 14 | Mudville | Rich Folkers |
| 15 | Flushing | Bob Montgomery |
| 16 | West Essex | Tom Norton |
| Round 6 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Jim McGlothlin |
| 2 | Springfield | Terry Humphrey |
| 3 | Tidewater | Jim Ray |
| 4 | Third Coast | Tom Phoebus |
| 5 | Wichita | Gary Thomasson |
| 6 | Kansas City | Jim Panther |
| 7 | Texas | Coco Laboy |
| 8 | Topsail Beach | Mel Queen |
| 9 | Mudville from Grindstone | Bill Stein |
| 10 | Cape Fear | Al Severinsen |
| 11 | Frankfort | Mickey Scott |
| 12 | Calgary | Gil Garrido |
| 13 | Cooperstown | Gary Ryerson |
| 14 | Mudville | Tim Cullen |
| 15 | Flushing | Dave Sells |
| 16 | West Essex | Jesus Alou |
| Round 7 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Casey Cox |
| 2 | Springfield | Bill Mazeroski |
| 3 | Tidewater | Don Hahn |
| 4 | Third Coast | Mike Tyson |
| 5 | Wichita | Jim Hardin |
| 6 | Kansas City | Bill Wilson |
| 7 | Texas | Dave Downs |
| 8 | Topsail Beach | Chris Short |
| 9 | Grindstone | Charlie Spikes |
| 10 | Cape Fear | Norm Miller |
| 11 | Frankfort | Wayne Simpson |
| 12 | Calgary | Curt Blefary |
| 13 | Cooperstown | Ted Ford |
| 14 | Mudville | John Morris |
| 15 | Flushing | Steve Brye |
| 16 | West Essex | Ed Farmer |
| Round 8 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Ken Reynolds |
| 2 | Springfield | Don Durham |
| 3 | Tidewater | Tom Kelley |
| 4 | Third Coast | Joe Lis |
| 5 | Wichita | Norm Angelini |
| 6 | Kansas City | Luis Alvarado |
| 7 | Texas | Damaso Blanco |
| 8 | Topsail Beach | Ray Culp |
| 9 | Grindstone | Frank Taveras |
| 10 | Cape Fear | Ed Crosby |
| 11 | Frankfort | Luis Melendez |
| 12 | Calgary | Don Carrithers |
| 13 | Cooperstown | Carl Taylor |
| 14 | Mudville | Duane Josephson |
| 15 | Flushing | Andy Kosco |
| 16 | West Essex | Bill Sudakis |
| Round 9 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Don Rose |
| 2 | Springfield | Joe Grzenda |
| 3 | Tidewater | Hal Lanier |
| 4 | Third Coast | Rich Hinton |
| 5 | Wichita | Johnny Jeter |
| 6 | Texas | Steve Lawson |
| 7 | Topsail Beach | Rich Morales |
| 8 | Cape Fear | Joe Lovitto |
| 9 | Frankfort | Ken Rudolph |
| 10 | Calgary | Pete LaCock |
| 11 | Cooperstown | Ed Spezio |
| 12 | Mudville | Jim Breazeale |
| 13 | Flushing | Jim Mason |
| Round 10 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Rod Gilbreath |
| 2 | Springfield | Steve Hamilton |
| 3 | Tidewater | Mark Schaeffer |
| 4 | Third Coast | Bill Plummer |
| 5 | Texas | Tom Dukes |
| 6 | Topsail Beach | Rickey Clark |
| 7 | Frankfort | Bob Veale |
| 8 | Calgary | Dave Leonhard |
| 9 | Cooperstown | Jim Lefebvre |
| 10 | Mudville | Dan Monzon |
| 11 | Flushing | Mike Strahler |
| Round 11 | ||
| 1 | Carolina | Jim York |
| 2 | Springfield | Denny McLain |
| 3 | Topsail Beach | Dalton Jones |
| 4 | Cooperstown | Don Mincher |
| Round 12 | ||
| 1 | Springfield | Donn Clendenon |
| 2 | Topsail Beach | Tony Cloninger |
| 3 | Cooperstown | Bob Didier |